Supporting Exercise Adherence in Chronic Low Back Pain: Barriers, Enablers, and Workplace Implications

Supporting Exercise Adherence in Chronic Low Back Pain: Barriers, Enablers, and Workplace Implications

How do barriers and enablers identified in recent qualitative research help us design more realistic, person‑centred exercise strategies for people living with chronic low back pain, including in workplace settings?

Gilanyi et al. (2024) conducted a qualitative systematic review that synthesised evidence on perceived barriers and enablers to exercise adherence among adults with nonspecific chronic low back pain (CLBP). The review identified four overarching themes-“exercise, pain, and the body,” “psychological factors,” “social factors,” and “external factors”-within which sixteen subthemes were described as influencing adherence. These subthemes were predominantly described as operating in both directions, acting as barriers and/or enablers depending on context, and were analysed in relation to pre‑exercise, during‑exercise, and post‑exercise time points. On this basis, the authors suggest that barriers and enablers may be better conceptualised along a continuum rather than as fixed categories, while noting that this interpretation arises from a synthesis of diverse qualitative reports rather than from population‑representative data.

Exercise, pain and the body

Within the theme “exercise, pain, and the body,” participants reported that increases in pain intensity or discomfort, and a perceived lack of meaningful pain relief, often discouraged initiating or continuing exercise, whereas meaningful reductions in pain during or after exercise, perceived improvements in functional capacity, enhanced mood, and perceived benefits for comorbid conditions were described as important motivators to continue. Other comorbidities (eg, arthritis, depression), unpleasant acute physiological responses to exercise (eg, sweating, dyspnoea, fatigue), and disability‑related limitations were reported as potentially impeding adherence, while improvements in fitness and strength were experienced as reinforcing continued exercise participation.

Key barriers identified in the review included:

  • Perceived worsening of pain or insufficient pain relief, functional limitations, comorbidities, and unpleasant physiological responses (eg, fatigue, breathlessness, sweating).
  • Low self‑efficacy and low motivation, not valuing exercise highly, fears of harm or lack of benefit, and a lack of enjoyment of prescribed activities.
  • Discouraging, mixed, or fear‑provoking messages, limited support or supervision from health professionals and significant others, and social environments experienced as uncomfortable or unsupportive.
  • Time and logistical constraints, limited access to facilities, programmes, or transport, unfavourable physical environments, and exercise types perceived as too difficult, monotonous, or incongruent with one’s self‑identity.

Key enablers identified in the review included:

  • Perceived meaningful pain relief, improvements in function, mood, physical fitness, and perceived benefits for other health conditions.
  • Higher exercise self‑efficacy, stronger motivation, placing greater value on and prioritising exercise, more positive health beliefs about exercise, and enjoyment of the chosen activities.
  • Clear, consistent, and supportive advice, encouragement from clinicians, family members, and peers, and access to a preferred or comfortable social context for exercising.
  • Manageable scheduling arrangements, good access to relevant resources, supportive physical and organisational environments, and exercise modalities that were simple, engaging, and perceived as compatible with one’s identity and preferences.

Limits of the current evidence

The evidence base in this review was restricted to studies conducted in high‑income, predominantly Western settings, with infrequent reporting of participants’ cultural background, socioeconomic status, gender identity, and life stage, thereby limiting the extent to which the findings can be transferred to other contexts. Gilanyi et al. (2024) also highlight a potential over‑representation of short‑term or trial‑based exercise experiences and an under‑representation of longer‑term exercise maintenance, recreational physical activity, and habit‑ or identity‑related processes, despite the latter being recognised in broader behaviour‑change literature as important predictors of sustained physical activity behaviour. The authors therefore argue that, in light of these limitations, the transferability of their findings to other populations and to longer‑term or non‑exercise‑specific physical activity behaviours should be regarded as uncertain and as requiring further empirical investigation.

What this may mean for practice

Overall, the review provides evidence that, for people with nonspecific CLBP in the included settings, exercise adherence appears to be shaped by a multifaceted interplay of bodily experiences, psychological processes, social interactions, and contextual constraints, which may operate as barriers or enablers along a continuum and at different time points relative to exercise. Gilanyi et al. (2024) propose that these synthesised themes could be used to inform the development of more individualised, theoretically informed strategies aimed at supporting longer‑term adherence to exercise in this population.

How FLOW applies these insights in clinical work

These findings suggest that exercise adherence for people with nonspecific lower back pain constitutes a multi‑layered, context‑sensitive process rather than a simple matter of “willpower” or programme design. In clinical practice, FLOW OSTEO therefore prioritises co‑creation of exercise plans that address experiences such as pain, fatigue, and comorbidities, psychological factors including self‑efficacy, beliefs, and motivation, social dynamics such as support, communication, and expectations, and the practical realities of each individual’s work and home environment.

Implications for workplace wellness

A workplace wellness day delivered through FLOW OSTEO is informed by these insights by offering targeted interventions that integrate education about pain and movement, individually adapted exercise options, and structured support that helps employees identify and problem‑solve real‑world barriers such as time pressure, access to facilities, and work‑related role demands. The overarching aim of this type of programme is to initiate a collaborative process in which employees recognise their own barriers and enablers and are guided towards ongoing resources and support that may, over time, enhance their capacity to adhere to exercise in a way that is sustainable within their everyday lives. Where appropriate, this process should be tailored to individual preferences and carried out in line with relevant clinical advice.

Gilanyi YL, Shah B, Cashin AG, Gibbs MT, Bellamy J, Day R, et al. Barriers and enablers to exercise adherence in people with nonspecific chronic low back pain: a systematic review of qualitative evidence. Pain. 2024;165(10):2200–2214.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *